Crewnerd gives a “check factor” metric of how well you are rowing. RIM has several metrics. Today I will discuss “stroke efficiency” and “check factor”.
I was interested to see what my model had to say about these metrics. Be aware that this post may tell as much about the imperfections of my model as about those two apps.
In this post I am going to look at the metrics for different force profiles during the stroke. These are the stroke force profiles I am using:
The ultimate efficiency measure of rowing is to get the maximum average boat speed at a given power. The below picture is a key picture calculates just that. The differences between the different stroke profiles are quite subtle.
So what does the graph tell us? First, that the differences in speed are very subtle. Still, it seems that red circles (T2) are the most efficient, lowest average power at a given average boat speed. Profile T5 seems to be the worst.
So how does Crewnerd’s “Check Factor” look like?
T5 is clearly the worst, giving the highest value of “check” at a given boat speed.
What is also clear is that to increase speed, one ends up inevitably with a higher value of “check”. Don’t try to minimize check at the cost of losing speed!
Now we turn to RIM. The RIM definition of “check” is just the difference between max and min boat speed.
So, at a given velocity, T2 is clearly the “lowest check” value and T5 the worst. It seems also RIM definition of “check” is useful.
RIM has another metric, “stroke efficiency”, defined as the integral of boat speed over one stroke, minus the integral of minimum boat speed. It measures how much further your stroke takes you compared to the minimum boat speed.
For this metric, higher is better. So again T5 scores the worst, and the best seems to be T3.
I think it is too early for conclusions, but here are some take away messages that I stick to for now:
- Expect any metric to change with boat speed and stroke rate. You should make sure you keep both constant if you try to optimize your stroke, which is difficult
- At given boat speed and stroke rate, the three tested metrics are consistent in the sense that optimizing them brings you to the most efficient power profile.
To be continued …